How We Rate Pipe Tobacco

Since we are reviewing more pipe tobacco on Cigar Federation it is time we put in a rating system. Rob and I worked together and come up with the following system.

We will take everything into account with the rating system include price, experience, flavors, availability, etc.

I hope you find my rating system easier to use, and if you have any feedback, please let us know.



5 Stars AKA "Stock Up" – Purchase multiple ounces for smoking and to age
4 Stars AKA "Keep in the Rotation" – Purchase enough to keep it in the rotation
3 Stars AKA "When it is on Sale" – Wouldn't pay full retail but would purchase it on sale
2 Stars AKA "Only when it is Free" - Would smoke a bowl if it was free and had nothing else
1 Star AKA "Never Again" - Wouldn't smoke it if it was given to me

© 2019   Created by Cigar Federation.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service