Last April the Reddit group /r/cigars had an entire month long ‘cold war’ where people were split into teams for the U.S.A. and Russia. Points were awarded for bombing the other side with cigars. The Mr. Sam I received was as a result of one of those exchanges.

I’m a huge fan of the La Palina Goldie No. 5, so I was eager to try out the Mr. Sam to see how it compared.

Rolled in the El Titan de Bronze factory in Miami, it was produced in a Robusto (4-3/4” x 54 RG), Corona (5.5” x 52 RG) and Toro (6” x 50 RG) sizes.


Vitola: Robusto

Size: 4-3/4” x 54 Ring Gauge

Wrapper: Ecuadorian Habano

Binder: Nicaragua

Filler: Nicaragua

Cigars Smoked for this Review: One per Reviewer

Price Point: $12.00

Cigar Purchased: Bomb from UnofficialGhost

Quick Note: For this review we used Logan’s rating system. You can view it in detail here.




Overall Cigar Federation Average Review: 90 AKA “Box Split”

“Every draw gives this perfect combination of complex flavors and just the right amount of pepper.”


Surgeon’s Review:

I took my time to examine the aromas here and the nose here was entirely cedar.

I did a single v-cut and it found the cold draw to be too tight so I ended up doing a double v-cut and the draw was perfect. I was able to pick up a fairly distinct black pepper on the cold draw.

My first few draws produced flavors of sweet honey with lots of pepper. The pepper doesn’t overpower the sweetness and I found it to be very tasty. This first third is so balanced. Every draw gives this perfect combination of complex flavors and just the right amount of pepper. Some cedar is introduced leading into the middle third.

In the middle third more of an earthy tone and the pepper has fallen off quite a bit. At this point it is still fantastic but the Goldie would edge out the Mr. Sam for me. At the halfway point I’m picking up some mintiness and the retrohale is entirely spice.

The last third is a bit simpler with cedar and an earth chaser to close out the cigar.

I’m splitting hairs here comparing the Mr. Sam to the La Palina Goldie No. 5.  The Mr. Sam is an absolute flavor treat and will undoubtedly find a home in the ever shrinking capacity of my humidor.


Views: 109

Comment by Matt Ross on October 28, 2014 at 6:35am

Big fan of the Mr.Sam, and really opened up the entire La Palina portfolio for me.  Even made my Top Cigars of 2013 list!

Comment by Dave Nichols on October 28, 2014 at 7:34am

I think it made a lot of people's top for 2013. It's definitely on my 'to try' list. 

Comment by Charlie on October 28, 2014 at 8:26am

The Sam and the Goldie are two very different blends, I would have to say that the corona is my favorite of the three Sam sizes...Great review!


You need to be a member of Cigar Federation to add comments!

Join Cigar Federation


  • Add Photos
  • View All


© 2020   Created by Cigar Federation.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service