Review: Gawith, Hoggarth & Co. Coniston Cut Plug

Consisting of 75% dark fired leaf and then equal parts of Burley and Virginia, Coniston Cut Plug should be a strong tobacco. It definitely smells  very strong and is extremely smokey. So, I'l light it up and see how it goes.

Coniston Cut Plug
Company: Gawith, Hogarth & Co.
How Packaged: Bulk
Style: Virgina/Burley
Tobacco Used: Virginia & Burley
Casing/Topping: None
Cut: Plug
Bowls Smoked: 2
Date Purchased/Obtained: 6/14/15
Storage Method: Mason Jar
Pipe(s) Used: Simple $40 pipe
Price Point: $3.75/oz
Purchased: Sample from another BOTL

Quick Note: To view the Pipe Tobacco rating system used, click here.

Tin/Jar Note: Very smokey. Lots of molasses and a smoked/dried prune or fig note.

Visual: Very dark plug that breaks up into this dark pile of strands.

Flavors: Strong. Smokey. And TONS of floral/rose petal notes.

Smoking Experience: This stuff produces a TON of smoke! It’s weird, but it leaves a soap-like mouth-feel. There is some natural tobacco flavor, but it mostly tastes like soapy floral notes. Had to relight a couple times, but it wasn’t unbearable. The flavor and mouthfeel were though.

Tobacco Strength: Strong

Body: Full

Room Note: Tolerable

Comparable Tobacco: This is way stronger than anything else I have smoked. Nor have I had this strong of a floral note before.

Conclusion: NOT my cup of tea here. It wasn't nicotine strong. It was floral strong. And the soapy feel, and for that matter, the soapy flavor it produced were Obviously, some people love this stuff, but it is not for me. That, or I am just not experienced enough yet to like it. Either way, this is probably more of a 1.5 for me. It's smokable, but I wouldn't choose it. And if it were free, there's a 50/50 chance I just wouldn't smoke.

Rating: 2 Stars AKA "Only when it is Free" - Would smoke a bowl if it was free and had nothing else.

Views: 60


You need to be a member of Cigar Federation to add comments!

Join Cigar Federation


  • Add Photos
  • View All


© 2019   Created by Cigar Federation.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service