Caldwell Eastern Standard

Size: 44 x 5.5

Vitola: Euro Express (Corona)

Wrapper: Connecticut Hybrid Ecadoriano (2006)

Binder: Habana Dominicano (2005)

Filler: Criollo ’98 Viso Dominicano 30% (2008), Corojo Dominicano Ligero 30% (2006) Habano Seco Nicaraguense 40% (2007)

Factory: Tabacalera Ventura

MSRP: $9.00

Cigars smoked for review: 1

Cigars for review provided by: Caldwell Cigar Co.

Note: For this review I used Cigar Federation's rating system


Prelight: The wrapper has a light, almost creamy aroma of white pepper, cedar and a little bit of natural sweetness. The cold draw is smooth, with flavors of cedar, grass and a touch of pepper spice.

Smoking: The first few puffs were strong and peppery, but that mellowed out quickly. And after a couple minutes, the flavors come into a very nice profile. Creamy, with flavors of lemon and cream are at the forefront. While wood and hay notes are in the background.

At the start of the second third, I got a very flavorful hit of almond. This blended very well with the wood, cream and lemon notes from the first third. And the smoke is pouring off this cigar in THICK white clouds.

Cedar and cream notes dominate in the final third, with the almond note waning in and out but still there. The lemon note has pretty much disappeared, although I do get hints of it now and then. The profile isn’t quite as smooth as the pepper has risen some, but it isn’t harsh.

Construction: The construction was very good. The burn was straight, minus two small touchups. The ash was tight and held on well too.

Final Thoughts: The lemon and cream notes in the first third and then the almond notes in the second third, were great. There was nothing wrong with the final third either, though. Great construction, a body/strength that stayed a solid medium and a pleasant profile make this a definite must try. Personally, it ends up as a middle of the road fiver for me.

Rating: 88 AKA "5-pack"

Views: 84

Comment by Sam C. on February 24, 2017 at 10:59pm
Great review! Haven't tried it in that lonsdale size, but that would've been a strong contender for my next size to try, and post review it remains that way. The corona sized Marble House from SBC is a big winner for me.

Comment by 007MI6 on February 25, 2017 at 11:01am

Thanks again Sam! Corona is a go to vitola for me. It is just hard to beat. As for this cigar, the flavors were very interesting and engaging. I'd definitely give it a try. :)

Comment by Sam C. on February 25, 2017 at 1:29pm
Will do!
Comment by MillerMan on February 25, 2017 at 5:50pm
Nicely done! Thanks


You need to be a member of Cigar Federation to add comments!

Join Cigar Federation


  • Add Photos
  • View All


© 2020   Created by Cigar Federation.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service