Pairing Review: The Smoking Monk of Esteli by Drew Estate Imperial Stout

In late 2014, Drew Estate announced the release of the Smoking Monk of Esteli series.  Each Smoking Monk cigar was blended to pair with a specific type of beer.  Naturally we got excited over at Sharing Our Pairings. Drew Estate blending cigars to be paired with beer is like a dream come true!

The Smoking Monk of Esteli line is exclusive to Cigars International and can be purchased from CI or from  In the coming weeks we will post reviews of each blend and also feature each Smoking Monk on Sharing Our Pairings.

Here is a look at each of the five blends:

Hefeweizen – Mild-bodied with creamy notes of vanilla and a sweet finish

Imperial Stout – Hearty, medium to full-bodied blend with nuances of cacao and sweetened dark roast coffee

American IPA – Medium-bodied with a zesty flavor profile of citrus, spice, and slight smoky finish

Porter – Well-balanced, medium-bodied blend filled with notes of dark chocolate, coffee, and caramel

Triple Belgian – Medium to full-bodied with a rich, complex tobacco flavor and a spicy finish

Obviously each cigar is blended to pair with a particular type of beer.  In the catalogue they take it one step further and give specific pairing recommendations.  The beers recommended for the Smoking Monk Imperial Stout are:

  • Founders Breakfast Stout (Michigan)
  • Old Rasputin Russian Imperial Stout (California)
  • Victory Storm King (Pennsylvania)

I decided to go with the Old Rasputin Russian Imperial Stout for a few reasons, but mainly because I could easily get my hands on it.  

The Smoking Monk of Esteli by Drew Estate Imperial Stout

Size: 6.5 x 54

Vitola: Toro

Wrapper: Maduro

 Binder: Undisclosed


Cigars Smoked for this Review: Two (1 solo, 1 paired)

Price Point: $9.00

Cigar Purchased: Samples provided by

Note: For this review I used the CF rating system. You can view it in detail here.

Cigar Notes:  The Smoking Monk of Esteli Imperial Stout has some interesting tobacco in it.  There has been some chatter about these cigars being infused and I can understand why.  I have no "inside knowledge," but I am confident that this particular blend is not infused.  It has some unique flavors and the aroma is quite pleasant, but it's not infused.  

The profile of the Smoking Monk Imperial stout was smooth with some sweet vanilla and fruit notes up front with a smoky finish.  There wasn't a ton of complexity or transition throughout and I think that makes it perfect for pairing.  The strength was a solid medium though I can see some folks calling it a full.  The construction was spot on with great smoke production and a sharp burn. 

This cigar was not blended to be smoked on its own, but it was still rather enjoyable.  There was enough flavor going on to keep me interested, but this thing really shines when paired.

Beer Notes: I'll preface this by saying that I am not a beer expert.  I really enjoy stouts and the Old Rasputin Russian Imperial Stout from North Coast Brewing happens to be in my regular rotation.  The flavors are big and bold while the texture is smooth and creamy.  The nose offers aromas of chocolate and coffee and the pour looks like something out of a Super Bowl commercial.  The mouthfeel is rich and smooth and the profile has a perfect balance of sweet and earth.  

The Old Rasputin is exactly what an imperial stout should be.  It packs a ton of flavor in a creamy profile with 9% abv.  If you like stouts, then you have probably had the Old Rasputin.  If you haven't had it, stop reading now and go get one.  I'll wait...

Pairing Notes: On the Sharing Our Pairings show we talk a lot about the goal of pairing.  Do you want to highlight the cigar?  Do you want to highlight the beverage?  Do you want them to complement each other or contrast each other?  In this case the thinking is done for you.  The Smoking Monk and Old Rasputin were quite simply (and possibly quite literally) made for each other.

The pairing of these two brings out the best in both.  The vanilla sweetness and smokey finish on the Smoking Monk are highlighted by the chocolate and coffee of the Old Rasputin.  This is one of the best pairings I have ever had.  Each element of the cigar and the beer seem to be intensified when paired.  It sounds like hyperbole, but they are a perfect match and I can't recommend this enough.

Cigar Rating:  87 AKA "5-Pack"

There is no question that I would grab a 5-Pack of these cigars to smoke on their own.  I like the sweetness of the tobacco and the aroma is attractive.  It's the kind of cigar I like to smoke while reading a book.  I can smoke it and enjoy it without thinking too much.  

Pairing Rating: 92 AKA "Box Split"

I'll happily grab 10 of these Smoking Monk Imperial Stout's and 10 of the Old Rasputin's.  The pairing is simply phenomenal.

Views: 629

Comment by Docwill on February 13, 2015 at 10:09am

Good looking stick.

Comment by Cigar Surgeon on February 13, 2015 at 10:15am

I'd be lying if I said this isn't the stick I'm looking forward to trying the most. As per previous shows stouts pair really well with a variety of beers so it will be interesting to see how the other pairings stand up.

Comment by Ky70 on February 13, 2015 at 11:25am

The cigar looks fantastic.  I enjoy the stout beers with lower ABV though so the Rasputin probably wouldn't be for me.  Considering the cigar has sweet vanilla, I would love to pair it with a tallgrass vanilla bean stout


You need to be a member of Cigar Federation to add comments!

Join Cigar Federation


  • Add Photos
  • View All


© 2019   Created by Cigar Federation.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service