Amateur Review: Black Label Trading Company Redemption 5x54

Back in early August, I did a blog on the full portfolio of Black Label Trading Company.  With the company set to debut on CigarChat with Rob and Logan later this week, I thought it was a good time to highlight those "reviews" to get every primed for Thursday night's show.  We'll begin with one that I enjoyed a lot - the Black Label Trading Company Redemption 5x54.

Typically, while I still don't claim to be a reviewer, I try not to smoke new cigars (to me) in the same day so I can fully savor the flavors of each cigar to gauge if I enjoy them or not.  However, since I was already at the shop on Thursday and had the Redemption in my herfador, and figured the Royalty was a bit on the lighter side, I decided to go against my typical plans and light up the Redemption as well.  I felt even more comfortable with this because the Redemption's Aged Nicaraguan Maduro wrapped Nicaraguan binder and filler provides probably the darkest cigar of the batch - a deep, deep chocolate brown.  Again, I'll note - and I haven't been looking for this - the foot band on the Redemption doesn't perfectly align with the main BL band.  Not sure why I note that, but it sticks out to me as I'm looking at the cigar.  Of the 4 BLTC blends I've now smoked for this blog, this is the first where the ash fell off pretty quickly - not even 1/4 of an inch in, and the ash fell; however, as I continued the ash would stay on for roughly an inch at a time.  Smoke output was again generous throughout.  Flavor-wise, this cigar really provides a lot of complexity although it surprises me by not providing the full-bodied power and strength I was expecting for some reason.  I get some hints of spice throughout, especially on the retrohale of the Redemption, but I'm quickly learning that spice is not a calling card of the BLTC blends (at least not for someone who regularly smokes fuller cigars like me).  The familiar cedar flavors I've noted in the other blends presents itself here with a definite leather - something I've struggled to find myself in cigars previously, but is obvious here.  At points I get some bitter sweetness which I attribute to coffee flavors.  Overall I can say that while I continually expect strong powerhouses from these BLTC blends, I'm consistently surprised by the uniqueness these blends provide.  It's hard for me to compare these to other cigars because I don't know too many Nicaraguan Maduro wrapped cigars with this flavor profile.  I'm eager for others to try these blends so I can get some comparison in my notes and begin some discussion on what these bring to the table.  At this point, I put this cigar in the same vicinity as the Last Rites in terms of my preferences of the line.

Views: 59

Comment by Generally Useful Jared on September 25, 2013 at 3:11pm

What's the price point on these, because they really sound good.

Comment by Matt Ross on September 25, 2013 at 7:05pm

I've heard $14 thrown around by a few people, but I don't know either way to be honest - we'll have to ask tomorrow on CigarChat.

Comment by Smokin Logan (Man Angel #1) on September 25, 2013 at 7:13pm

I am pretty sure it is $14. I will make sure to ask tomorrow.

Comment by Generally Useful Jared on September 25, 2013 at 8:06pm
Whew, ok. That would qualify as a special occasion stick for me. I'll keep that in mind.


You need to be a member of Cigar Federation to add comments!

Join Cigar Federation


  • Add Photos
  • View All


© 2019   Created by Cigar Federation.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service