Ha, I wondered if that comment would spur a nice discussion. :)
Illusione would definitely warrant a high possibility for me, but I would honestly say with the most high quality consistency, Warped and RoMa Craft. I've yet to come across a bad cigar from either one of these companies. The greatest part about that is neither company is all that large. Instead, they focus on making quality products and it shows in each and every experience I've had. The other part is both companies offer me completely different experiences with their lineup. I'd never get bored.
Rocky Patel and Drew Estate. I think between those two I could smoke a new cigar every day for a year. Also they each make a few really good cigars that I never get bored with smoking.
Tabaquero , Prohibition, Royale and Decade are all really good.
Tatuaje and Padron. Boom goes the dynamite!
I like the way you think Jason
For me it would be Tatuaje & Illusione
Ortega Series D #7 Maduro..not sure what the second brand would be.
I could probably spend days debating my choices, so I'm going to go with the first 2 that came to mind. RoMa and Tatuaje.