I'll go with my current top 5 maduros in no particular order:
Padron 1926 No. 35
RoMa Craft Neanderthal
LFD La Nox
Maya Selva Maduro
L'Atelier La Mission
These are all tried a true smokes for me, that have been out for a while, and I always enjoy smoking them.
Sorry you got caught. Pretty cool of you to do this man.
Top 5 Want to Smoke:
Opus X (can't bring myself to pay for one, curious)
Ezra Zion Chocolate Porter
top 5 contenders for my cigar of the year (off the top of my head in no particular order):
Sobremesa Short Churchill
All Out Kings Toro
BLK_WKS Green Hornet