Welcome aboard Eric! There is no doubt you can get sucked in to this site, but it's worth it! What kind of cigars do you find yourself smoking these days? Or if you're like me, everything. ;)
Cigars that I have smoked that I have really enjoyed in the last couple of weeks are
Intemperance BA XXI Robusto
Recluse Draconian Toro
RP Decade Sumatra Robusto
RP 1990 Vintage Robusto
RP 1992 Vintage Churchill
Herrera Esteli Extra Robusto
Oliva Serie V Lancerco
These were not so good
Punch after dinner maduro
Natural by Drew Estate
Alec Bradley American Sun grown Blend- too much strength for me
RoMa Craft is legit. One of the few cigars I religiously buy is the Intemperence EC The Faith. Great Connecticut and I love the vitola. Not a big Rocky fan, but the Herrera Esteli & V Lancero are tasty.
I like the Natural. It's not a standard go to, but I find it's a pleasant and cheap infused cigar. For when I want something different. Sounds like you are not an infused kinda guy.
Welcome to CF, Eric!
Welcome Eric! You'll find a lot of great recommendations here and good people too. Off the top of my head seeing what you've enjoyed, I'd recommend trying Mombacho Tierra Volcan and if you enjoyed the Sumatra, try Crowned Heads Headley Grange. Both are good values for the price and solid medium strength with lots of flavor. Cheers!