Its that time of year again and we've already seen a few Top lists come out. Got me thinking - if you made a list for Top Cigars of 2014, what would be on it?
We're doing things slightly different this year, and we want your help. Beginning later today, we will begin announcing the Top 10 Cigars on Cigar Federation's Top New Releases of 2014 (#10 will be posted today, and #1 will be announced on December 19th). I'll track the list here, but we also want to put together a FedHead Group List. If you'd like to participate, please respond to this post and tell us your Top 10 Cigars Released in 2014.
Please note that the only requirement is that your list include only cigars released this year! If you only have 1 2014 release that makes the list, or you have 20, that's fine - we want you to join the discussion so share with us. At the end, I will tally up all the votes, and we'll add to the discussion!
Here is what has currently been announced from the Cigar Federation Top New Releases of 2014:
To see last year's list, click here.
#1 Herrera Esteli Norteno is my top pick. I had the toro especial.
#2 Has to be Ezra Zion Tantrum PA.
Two box-pressed cigars at opposite ends of scale and size, power and subtlety.
#3 Caldwell Cigars, Long Live The King. Allegiance has been paid to beauty and strength.
I love the EZ Tantrum PA!
Okay #10-6 are posted. What do we think so far? What do you agree with? Disagree with? What's your Top 10?
To be honest I've only smoked the Warped FDV and I wouldn't put it one my top 10 (but the La Colmena would make the list).
Great to see Nomad get some love! Made the list 2x!
Thanks Charlie...we are thrilled as well :)
My head hurts now but below is my top 10 list (in alphabetical order).
|Bodega Reunion Digestivo|
|Caldwell Long Live the King|
|Ezra Zion FHK|
|Illusione Cigars Privé MC Slam|
|La Colmena Amado No. 44|
|La Palina Black Label|
|Principle Trading Special Edition KBF Churchill (no clue when this was released)|
|Regius Exclusivo U.S.A. (red label)|
|Regius Seleccion Orchant Campana|
What does everyone think about our list so far? I've heard a lot of feedback - good and bad - but I'm curious what the majority thinks.
What do you think will make #1 and #2 on our list?
Also, don't forget to share your own personal list for the FedHead Group discussion.
The issue is what is your vision for the Top 10. I think you guys have been pretty up front to say you are Boutique Focused. In that case, you kept to your vision and did a good job. Whether I agree with the cigars or not is besides the point. You articulated the vision.
Personally, I think you guys are missing a large segment of the market with what you cover. I think you aren't just boutique focused, but you are small boutique focused. That's just my opinion, but I think you guys could really benefit from reviewing more Davidoff, Fuente, Atladis and General as well as the "larger boutiques" like Quesada, Nat Sherman, Illusione, and Tatuaje. Not saying you should have those on the list. In general, I'd like to see more coverage from Cig Fed on those brands.
In the end, nobody's list is right or wrong - and it should create some interesting discussion.